Mitchell entered Indy as a conduit for mid-range and downfield looks, with the Colts leaning on him in routes that challenge coverages. His usage hints at a growing trust curve as the offense finds rhythm around the new quarterback dynamics.

Mitchell emerged as a high-upside holdover in a crowded Colts WR room, showing substantial open-downfield potential per Open Score in 2024. With Pittman as the primary target and Tyler Warren adding a rookie red-zone weapon, Mitchell’s clean release and connection timing could translate into a breakout year if QB play stabilizes. His development is central to how much Indianapolis can score this season.

Mitchell lands in a crowded Indy WR room behind Pittman, Downs, and Pierce; a first-round TE in Warren and a QB situation that could be shaky reduces his immediate value. Without a clear path to targets, he’s a fade in standard formats.

Mitchell shows promise in Colts camp as a sophomore who has demonstrated separation and big-play ability. With a quarterback transition and a receiving corps that needs a reliable deep threat, Mitchell is positioned as a late-round candidate who could capitalize on a growing role.

Mitchell’s speed remains a weapon for a Colts unit seeking deeper playmaking. If he improves efficiency and gains confidence in the route tree, he could push Alec Pierce for a starting perimeter role and yield sleeper-week upside in deep formats.